So I have been thinking. A lot of topics have really made me wonder a few things.
I just want to know what you think.
Follow with me if you will.
Here is the scenerio:
There is a Christmas program to help a family for the holidays. There is just one slot left. Who should get the opening? Family A or Family B? For the sake fo arguement they both have the same income and same amount of kids.
Family A is an avid coupon user, sale seeker and deal finder. They dont impulse buy much. They have a nice cushion in their savings.
Family B is a hot mess when it comes to budgeting. Impulse buys. Has no savings.They constantly over buy.
Christmas time rolls around. Family A could afford to have a small Christmas. Family B is broke, as usual.
Who gets the last slot?
Family A.
Family B needs to learn a lesson. That is harsh.. but maybe after their kids have a lame Christmas, they will make a New Year's resolution to learn how to be better with money.
The kids probably won't even remember they had a bad Christmas once, anyways.
My instincts would be to go with Family A; even though Family B is in a "hot mess" as you say giving them a handout would only cause them to further rely on programs such as these.
Well, okay.. I read it again.
And that's hard.
I don't know. :(
But it's not fair for Family B to get it when they probably have a lot of nice things for themselves that they bought on impulse.
Again I will say cant fix the parents.. but can give hope and guide a child every time.. my choice is divide , make it work for both.. Xtmas is not about gifts.. but gifts are about children ..
even though Family B is in a "hot mess" as you say giving them a handout would only cause them to further rely on programs such as these.
Maybe that's what I was trying to say!!
Well if Family A has a nice cushion in savings and can budget then why would they need help?
Family B needs to learn and not depend on others because they made stupid mistakes!
Family A. They're trying hard and at least know how to budget.
Family B are impulse buyers. So it's not like they had to "sacrifice" anything for their impulse buys.
That is hard. On one hand it isn't the children's fault their parents can't budget and should get something for Christmas. On the other hand family A saves their money and is smart and has literally worked hard for what they own. I am going to say A deserves it more but for the sake of the children it should go to B since A can afford a little bit. It is a sad but I think that the ones who don't budget and overspend shouldn't be able to use programs.
I say family A...they are making good choices to thrive and save. If family B received the help, it would likely go to the wrong things OR they would take it for granted and continue their sick cycle of poor and over spending :(
Leading? Maybe.
I dont know. Seems like this scenerio happens a lot.
You wanna help the family in need but you also want to reward the family who does well.
Do you really let kids go without some sort of Christmas....
All abouts suggested splitting the budget... sounds like a good plan. That way family A can suppliment their small Christmas and family B's kids get SOMETHING for Christmas.
All abouts suggested splitting the budget... sounds like a good plan. That way family A can suppliment their small Christmas and family B's kids get SOMETHING for Christmas.
Its one or the other. No programs split.
I am thinking family A should get the help. You said a small savings which could be anything maybe its only a few hundred dollars or something. They may need to save that for emergencies. I think giving the program help to family B is how people turn out so greedy. They figure oh we don't need to save we will get something free later.
IMO Neither...Be thankful for your family, health and time together, the fact that they DO have a job (as LOTS of people dont)..things like being with your family are priceless
family A because even though they have savings that for saving...
family B needs to learn that not every day is Christmas and needs to learn the hard way
family A because even though they have savings that for saving...
family B needs to learn that not every day is Christmas and needs to learn the hard way
Some people just take advantage of programs like that...and others such as government programs for aid. I don't think B deserves it at all. Family A works hard and deserves to be rewarded.
kids on family A will have some.. so kids on family B needs more
but.....kids on family B probably have been getting "new things" all year. as Family A kids only get things when its "a holiday or birthday"....im torn
I totally already commented.. but this is super annoying to me. For several years of my life, it was just my dad and I. He was 24 when my mom left, and I was three. Somehow for the next few years he managed to provide birthday parties, Christmas presents, cute school clothes.. AND buy us a house. He might have had a little help from my grandma, but really.. all she did was cook us dinner once or twice a week because she lived so close.
Knowing that about how hard my dad worked to raise me and provide for me.. not just essentials, but the fun stuff, too.. makes me REALLY hate irresponsible parents!!
I would give to family B.. see my goal is not to punished the kids.so kids on family B needs more
see thats just stupid b.c what if the kids have d.s, the wii, etc...
and family A...is RESPONSIBLE!!
its parents that care for their kids...meaning giving them a good Christmas and not having others provide for them when they cant manage their money!