Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Woman Terminates Adoption

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
VivaLaDoll 5
TheNinja 1
εїзJelly_Bean 3
ღHollyDeeღ 1
Mckees Wifey 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

VivaLaDoll --- 17 years ago -

Woman Terminates Adoption Because She Can't Bond With The Child link Of human bondage? The "Today" show on NBC did a shocking segment on Anita Tedaldi, "a woman who adopted a child and then gave him up 18 months later." Tedaldi is a writer who originally told this story on The New York Times' Motherlode blog. She and her husband have five biological children and decided that they wanted more. After going through the approval process, she was able to adopt a baby who was found by the side of a road. Despite her pre-adoption belief that she would "be able to parent this little boy the same way I had done with my biological daughters," she terminated the adoption after 18 months. Because she couldn't bond with him, she said. Asked by Matt Lauer what this means, Tedaldi was somewhat vague and did manage to blame the baby. "It went both ways," she said in the interview. "The child, D., wasn't connecting with us." What on earth is she talking about? Without giving us particulars, we're left to wonder what went on in that house for a year-and-a-half? Was Baby D. not a hugger? Did he not smile? What does it mean exactly that an infant is not bonding with his mother? Lauer really missed the boat by not pressing this question. And Tedaldi, but averting a direct explanation, only adds to the frustration and creates more questions. Writing about the story, "Today" correspondent Natalie Morales thinks that we shouldn't be too quick to judge the woman. Many commenters on the "Today" show Web site agree. But what no one is saying is that ultimately this story is about the one thing that it shouldn't be about -- Anita Tedaldi. One of the not-discussed-enough aspects of the mommy blogosphere is how often it becomes All About Mom. This story is a classic case of that. Not only did Tedaldi give back a baby she had decided to adopt, she actually says that the baby shares some of the responsibility for this lack of bonding. Is it possible that it's just damn hard to raise a baby when you already have a house full of children? And that Tedaldi didn't realize this until the child arrived? Explain it to us, lady. What happened? Ironically, Tedaldi used to feel the same way we did, and wrote a column for Military.com called "We Can't Trade In Our Children or Husbands" back in January 2008. (Military.com has pulled the piece, but the Adoption Talk blog has some of the text.) Now that she has had this experience, she feels differently. Hey, no harm no foul, right? But there is harm. There is a baby involved here. In the original Times blog, Tedaldi wrote that she "wasn't connecting with [the baby] on the visceral level I experienced with my biological daughters." Perhaps that was part of the problem? She wanted to duplicate her parenting experience with her older kids frame-for-frame. We have no way of knowing unless we hear details. Many are praising this mom for her honesty. We can't help but wonder how much of the story she decided not to share with the world.  

VivaLaDoll --- 17 years ago -

Terminating an Adoption: Will the Real Anita Tedaldi Please Stand Up? That NYT blog piece by Anita Tedaldi about her disrupted adoption? Well, she wrote this article, We Can't Trade In Our Children or Husbands, in January 2008: Hard to believe, but a Dutch couple returned their adopted Korean daughter after seven years. [I blogged about this case here]. The parents adopted the little girl from South Korea when she was 4 months old. Reports of how the situation unfolded were contradictory but it appears that thegirl was given over to the care of the Social Welfare Department in Hong Kong, where the man is a diplomat, because they could no longer care for her. The couple explained that the girl was emotionally unresponsive and all attempts at therapy failed. As an adoptive parent, really as just a parent, I can't justify this couple's behavior under any circumstance. I don't think these people are monsters, though the result of their action is monstrous because they chose to follow their selfish and unloving side instead of choosing to tough it out and love their daughter no matter what. Sadly, the impact on this child will be devastating. Perhaps they had good intentions when they adopted, most likely they did, but something went wrong along the way. These parents were probably unprepared to deal with some difficult aspects of adoption. It's easy to imagine only the best of a new family member, just as we do with our biological children. No one envisions mediocrity, let alone problems. I have imagined perfect things in the past only to discover the road to family or marital bliss requires lots of hard work and an effort to practice unconditional love. * * * From personal experience I can say that adoption can be challenging. But so can a biological child who has issues, or problems in marriage, or work-related difficulties. When our adopted son Matteo started having health issues we had to consult several specialist and it was hard for him to be around his sisters, it became challenging. This doesn't mean that my husband or I ever had any second thoughts about adopting Matteo, or that we considered him any different than our biological children. So is Matteo a pseudonym? In the NYT article she uses the initial D., and in a comment she posted to that article, she called him David (BTW, in that comment, she also said she had 3 children at the time she adopted D., and then had 2 more after D.'s adoption). Is this the same child? If so, then in January 2008 she had no second thoughts, and in August 2009, she tells us about the disruption like it happened a while ago. Pretty quick to go from couldn't-imagine to done-deal. Sheesh, who IS this woman?! Or does this simply represent her right to change her mind? She also says in the NYT piece that she didn't know where the idea to return D. came from when it popped into her head -- ya think Jade's story might have had something to do with it?! She acts in that article like she'd never even heard of disruption before . Those who are praising her honesty in writing that blog post, regardless of opinions about the disruption, might want to think again. . . . UPDATE UPDATE UPDATE UPDATE UPDATE UPDATE I CANNOT believe it! Military.com has scrubbed it's site to take down the article by Anita Tedaldi that I linked to above! You click on it now, you get a generic page about columnists, not even an ERROR 404 message, nothing to show the article previously existed there. If you do a search of the site for Tedaldi's name, you find two other articles by her, but not this one. In fact, the search page shows the two results, but at the top it says "Results 1-2 of about 3 [about 3?!]." And at the bottom it says, "In order to show you the most relevant results, we have omitted some entries very similar to the 2 already displayed. If you like, you can repeat the search with the omitted results included." But when you click to get the omitted results, nothing else comes up! WTF??? I'm a military brat, my dad was career Air Force. I'm appalled by this. Any guesses why they scrubbed it clean? I can't tell you how happy I am that I snipped this portion of the article before it was made to vanish. 

VivaLaDoll --- 17 years ago -

I tried to add the video not working.. 

εїзJelly_Bean --- 17 years ago -

idk y but i think its kind of a publicity thing....... 

VivaLaDoll --- 17 years ago -

I think she has mental issues and I just feel so bad for that baby boy. First his bio parents and now his adoptive ones :( He is going to have a rough time growing up and later in life if he can't find a stable home. I just hope he has a real permanent family now who loves him and cares for him. 

εїзJelly_Bean --- 17 years ago -

shes a writer and i kinda thinks its a way to get her blog out there and her writing out there. bad press is press. and press is good when your trying to get a name. look at octomom 

VivaLaDoll --- 17 years ago -

Yeah something is up I mean why come forward with all of this?? Going on a talk show? There is nothing to be proud of here and she isn't some victim. 

TheNinja --- 17 years ago -

! :( I'll take them!!!! If not me, I know plenty of people that would take those children in a heartbeat. 

εїзJelly_Bean --- 17 years ago -

Not only did Tedaldi give back a baby she had decided to adopt, she actually says that the baby shares some of the responsibility for this lack of bonding. Is it possible that it's just damn hard to raise a baby when you already have a house full of children? And that Tedaldi didn't realize this until the child arrived?  

ღHollyDeeღ --- 17 years ago -

OMG That is horrible. This woman obviously has mental issues. IF she did do it for publicity, then shame on her!!! I hope karma comes back around to bite her in her selfish asss hard!!! 

ALEM --- 17 years ago -

I skimmed the article. While what she did, isn't the best for either party. Atleast she didnt do something irrational to the child (something fatal) because she couldn't bond with him. 

Mckees Wifey --- 17 years ago -

i don't see why ppl would judge her for giving him up...it's what's best for the child(which is most important)... a bond is a two way street and obviously it just wasn't there. i mean, it's got to be really hard on the child emotionally too ya kno? like it's obvious to the child(having 5 other siblings) that he doesn't belong somehow. honestly i don't think i could adopt a child that isn't of my heritage considering how emotionally unstable the child could become from being around only Hispanic ppl...like if i were to adopt a Chinese baby. i think the child will grow up knowing something isn't right..and that's just awful to put a child thru those kind of emotions.. i think she did the right thing. and plus, it's not like she didn't try!! this is just my opinion, not picking on race or adopted kids.. just commenting :D 

Mckees Wifey --- 17 years ago -

! :( I'll take them!!!! If not me, I know plenty of people that would take those children in a heartbeat. it was one child...the other 5 were her biological children...lol. ;) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground