Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

mercy rule for kids sports

who's talking here?

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co 8
G's Wifey 3
Christina 3
Ruthie 3
NOTW 4
ChrisSki 4
Brookelynn's Mommy 2
Bo§§ Lady 3
B*Bright 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ChrisSki --- 17 years ago -

Do you think at a certain age they should lift the mercy rule for kids sports? If so, what age do you think? If not, why not? 

Christina --- 17 years ago -

i dotn have kids that old yet... what is the mercy rule? 

ChrisSki --- 17 years ago -

A mercy rule is when a team or a certain player is doing too well they make them back off. 

G's Wifey --- 17 years ago -

A mercy rule is when a team or a certain player is doing too well they make them back off. Why should a kid back off? If anything that kid should be bumped up to the next level in that sport. I think the "mercy rule" holds back a really talented kid by making him not try/compete as hard. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

if your child was excelling in math would you make him back off because there are some with D's??? I think the mercy rule is pretty stupid....but thats just my opinion.....some people are better at some sports than others...they shouldn't have to be mediocre because someone else is having a hard time keeping up.... but then again, i see the other side to it who's kid is the one who isn't to good at the sport....it makes them feel bad.... 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

Don't get me started... 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

get started, get started...LOL...i wanna know what you think... 

Bo§§ Lady --- 17 years ago -

Why should a kid back off? If anything that kid should be bumped up to the next level in that sport. I think the "mercy rule" holds back a really talented kid by making him not try/compete as hard. I couldn't agree more. When I was high school it was tougher for us to wrestle other teams because we had to go out of our district. No one in our district wanted to duel with us. It sucked. 

Christina --- 17 years ago -

hmmm... that is a really good question. I played a lot of sports and some better than others obviously. I dont have kids this age so not sure my opinion is valid? but i think the mercy rule is totally appropriate for kids... until highschool. Not every child has the opportunity for their dad to say.. shoot around with a basketball with them. so if one child already has experience and the other is getting thiers by playing a team sport its not really fair. It sucks cuz i can imagine if my kid were doing amazing i would be pretty annoyed if they got pulled out of the game. but i hope when the time comes i can still understand. i think highschool is an appropriate age becuase scouts from colleges are looking at these kids and then its much more competetive. my husband was scouted for football for st. marys college. this is a really interesting question and a really good one too! i love it.actually makes you think. if im being totally unbias its probably good to have the rule in for both kids. idk. ? what do you think OP? 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

This happened to my kid two games ago. He made like 5 goals in the first 20 minutes and the refs called him out of the entire half so the other team could catch up. My son thought he did something wrong and then intentionally stayed back the next game in fear he would be kicked out again. 

Christina --- 17 years ago -

This happened to my kid two games ago. He made like 5 goals in the first 20 minutes and the refs called him out of the entire half so the other team could catch up. My son thought he did something wrong and then intentionally stayed back the next game in fear he would be kicked out again. :( aw thats really sad, what a bummer, see likei said my little ones are so small i havent had to experience this yet, but that sounds awful. poor kid 

ChrisSki --- 17 years ago -

Here's why I am asking. My sons soccer team has been doing very well at the games and has been asked to back off every single game so far. I feel like they are at the age that they are there to win and that they pratice really hard to win so why make them back off? I do however see the other point of not making the other kids feel bad. I guess I'm just torn on it and wanted to see what others thought. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

This happened to my kid two games ago. He made like 5 goals in the first 20 minutes and the refs called him out of the entire half so the other team could catch up. My son thought he did something wrong and then intentionally stayed back the next game in fear he would be kicked out again. see, i DO NOT agree with that. why should your son be penalized for doing good!! What if it were a test instead of a game? Like a spelling quiz? Should our kids misspell words on purpose because some kids are illiterate or dyslexic or something? NO, you would want your kid to be the best at what he is good at! Not half-a** it because someone is not as good as you..... 

G's Wifey --- 17 years ago -

...... I hate when parents don't want their kids to compete. Life is full of competition and I believe sports at a young age helps to instill that in a child. Competition is great. 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

This happened to my kid two games ago. He made like 5 goals in the first 20 minutes and the refs called him out of the entire half so the other team could catch up. My son thought he did something wrong and then intentionally stayed back the next game in fear he would be kicked out again. WTF?! That's the mercy rule????!!! I thought the mercy rule was "stop hurting me" like saying uncle. Uhm, I think this new age Mercy Rule is crap. But that's just me. My entire family has played sports and never had a mercy rule...is this a California thing, on base thing? 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

to some people sports are natural (i am not one of those people) and to some it's a lost cause (that would be me) I would not want someone to take it easy on me and make me think I'm better than i am because they feel sorry for me. the kids will figure it out one day that soccer, basketball, etc. is not their thing and they will get over it and move on like the rest of the world does.... 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

would not want someone to take it easy on me and make me think I'm better than i am because they feel sorry for me. Yeah and I'm sure the kids feel the same way. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

maybe if the kid was showboating saying "yeah we rock...you guys suck..your losing and your a loser...stupid losers" then maybe i would pull that kid out....but not for being good...for being a little brat.... 

Bo§§ Lady --- 17 years ago -

My son isn't near the age to be playing sports or competing, but if he were I wouldn't expect him to back off if he excelled at something, be it sports or school work. He's not going to be good at everything and one day he'll have to understand that. 

G's Wifey --- 17 years ago -

Here's another thought..... Do you think Kobe Bryant or any professional athlete was told to hold back and if they did, do you think they would be where they are today? Competition is healthy and necessary. 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

Thats poor sportsmanship and can never be tolerated. It took a week of me reminding him that he was just at a higher skill level than most and it in no way means he should stop being the best he can be. Its flipping nuts. See, my son has a learning disability and is in a self contained class. He is at the age where he knows all his friends attend another school and he is not as "smart" (his words not mine.) Soccer is his thing. He excels in it. He loves it and it's his world. For them to say he can't play because he is too good burns my azz. How dare they take his only sense of pride away?! 

NOTW --- 17 years ago -

Ok...as a former "soccer is my life" girl, I have to put in my opinion...general youth sports is the place for "beginners"...so that everyone gets to learn and play, I see no problem having this type of "rule"...HOWEVER, if kids are playing on travelling or club teams, there is no room for this "rule"...kids need to understand that you will win some and you will lose some and to ALWAYS give 110% at every game whether or not they win...it is not only a sports/competition lesson but also an overall general life lesson 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

so that everyone gets to learn and play, I see no problem having this type of "rule".. Yeah, but pulling someone out because they are good is wrong. I don't think they should play the whole game either. But let's say everyone plays an average of 15 minutes a game if everyone is rotated and bla bla bla. Johnny only gets to play 5 minutes because he scored too many goals too soon. Those are just easy numbers, but it gets the point across of why I think the "mercy rule" is flawed. 

ChrisSki --- 17 years ago -

I can't quote, on my phone, but you have a good point Wishing I was back east! 

Brookelynn's Mommy --- 17 years ago -

.general youth sports is the place for "beginners"...so that everyone gets to learn and play, I see no problem having this type of "rule"...HOWEVER, if kids are playing on travelling or club teams, there is no room for this "rule"...kids need to understand that you will win some and you will lose some and to ALWAYS give 110% at every game whether or not they win...it is not only a sports/competition lesson but also an overall general life lesson I agree with you completely. I find it very unfair for them to take PP's son out of the game because he can make more goals than anyone else. On the other side though, how would you all feel if it was your child who was on the team that ALWAYS lost by a lot? 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

Youth sports is for kids of all levels. It just means the sport is for youth. If the base offered a different option I could see that being reasonable. They don't. The rule blows. 

Brookelynn's Mommy --- 17 years ago -

Maybe to solve the issue, instead of doing sports by age, they should do them by experience. 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

I agree with you completely. I find it very unfair for them to take PP's son out of the game because he can make more goals than anyone else. On the other side though, how would you all feel if it was your child who was on the team that ALWAYS lost by a lot If you play the sport enough you will know that there will always be a season when the kids just don't win. They don't communicate and they just aren't playing well. That doesn't mean you make it easier for them. Its a life lesson learned...play harder. 

NOTW --- 17 years ago -

the only way to get better is to play better teams, to have competition, to challenge your own skills, to practice...another thing to consider is the coaching...it is one thing to just "volunteer" to coach not knowing anything about the sport and to actually COACH and TEACH the kids how to play and practice... 

NOTW --- 17 years ago -

If you play the sport enough you will know that there will always be a season when the kids just don't win. They don't communicate and they just aren't playing well. That doesn't mean you make it easier for them. Its a life lesson learned...play harder. AMEN....PLAY HARDER!!!!!!!! LEARN...AND PLAY HARDER!!!! yes, kids will get their feelings hurt, yes, they will feel bad...if they don't learn that lesson now...where are they gonna be when they grown up and "oh no, this company isn't gonna make it easier for me to get a raise or get promoted...they don't care about my feelings" 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground