Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Children aren't yours, still pay child support?

who's talking here?

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co 3
gidget 1
B Bright 1
whatevergirl ツ 2
mommyof2xs1y 1
Ruthie 6
M.o.d.sfixyourself 1
Moving to Texas 1
Ange 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Children aren't yours, still pay child support?

Say What?! Yeah, check this article out. Not long after Pasqualino Cornelio got married, he was thrilled to learn his wife was pregnant with twins. The two babies were born healthy and have since grown into 16-year-old teenagers who have suddenly found themselves at the centre of a bizarre court case that's sparked controversy across Ontario. It started back in 1998 when the marriage of their parents unraveled and the couple separated in a bitter break-up. Cornelio has been making child support payments ever since. But when his estranged wife recently demanded more money for their upkeep and cut back on his visitation time with them, an angry Cornelio decided to take drastic measures. He got a DNA test and discovered to his surprise that the twins weren't really his. Instead, they were the result of an affair his wife had while they were together, one he never knew about. Those test results led Cornelio to get a lawyer and try to put an end to the payments and get his money back, arguing that he wasn't the biological father and therefore shouldn't be paying the freight for someone else's children. But an Ontario Superior Court judge has ruled that, despite his wife's infidelity, he still has a duty to support the kids because he's the only father they've ever known. In effect, Justice Katherine van Rensburg is siding not with the parents, but the children, who would be victimized by a stoppage in payments from the man they consider to be their dad. "The right to child support is the right of a child, and is independent of a parent's own conduct." she stated. "(This man) was the only father the twins knew during the course of the marriage." Why can't the real father step up to the payment table? Cornelio's wife claims she has no memory of having any affair and has no idea who the actual dad might be. The case has now led to a huge controversy across the province, with many wondering if a man should be forced to support someone else's offspring in the face of such deception. "I think it's a good ruling," states family law specialist Brahm Siegel. "I think it's a clear recognition (that) the utmost importance in determining cases like this, is the relationship between the child and the non-biological father, not so much whose D.N.A. is lodged in a child's cells." But the director of a father's rights group thinks the wife's deception should be penalized "Any time that you have a fraud committed, there should be something to be done to correct it. You don't just say, 'Well that's fine you committed a fraud, congratulations,' there's no consequence," said Brian Jenkins of Fathers Are Capable Too. [Link To Article] Question: Do you think the man should still have to pay child support for the children?

Yes Vote
 
 17.4% (4)
No Vote
 
 78.3% (18)
Maybe So/Don't Know/Will Explain Vote
 
 4.3% (1)
Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

Say What?! Yeah, check this article out. Not long after Pasqualino Cornelio got married, he was thrilled to learn his wife was pregnant with twins. The two babies were born healthy and have since grown into 16-year-old teenagers who have suddenly found themselves at the centre of a bizarre court case that's sparked controversy across Ontario. It started back in 1998 when the marriage of their parents unraveled and the couple separated in a bitter break-up. Cornelio has been making child support payments ever since. But when his estranged wife recently demanded more money for their upkeep and cut back on his visitation time with them, an angry Cornelio decided to take drastic measures. He got a DNA test and discovered to his surprise that the twins weren't really his. Instead, they were the result of an affair his wife had while they were together, one he never knew about. Those test results led Cornelio to get a lawyer and try to put an end to the payments and get his money back, arguing that he wasn't the biological father and therefore shouldn't be paying the freight for someone else's children. But an Ontario Superior Court judge has ruled that, despite his wife's infidelity, he still has a duty to support the kids because he's the only father they've ever known. In effect, Justice Katherine van Rensburg is siding not with the parents, but the children, who would be victimized by a stoppage in payments from the man they consider to be their dad. "The right to child support is the right of a child, and is independent of a parent's own conduct." she stated. "(This man) was the only father the twins knew during the course of the marriage." Why can't the real father step up to the payment table? Cornelio's wife claims she has no memory of having any affair and has no idea who the actual dad might be. The case has now led to a huge controversy across the province, with many wondering if a man should be forced to support someone else's offspring in the face of such deception. "I think it's a good ruling," states family law specialist Brahm Siegel. "I think it's a clear recognition (that) the utmost importance in determining cases like this, is the relationship between the child and the non-biological father, not so much whose D.N.A. is lodged in a child's cells." But the director of a father's rights group thinks the wife's deception should be penalized "Any time that you have a fraud committed, there should be something to be done to correct it. You don't just say, 'Well that's fine you committed a fraud, congratulations,' there's no consequence," said Brian Jenkins of Fathers Are Capable Too. [Link To Article] Question: Do you think the man should still have to pay child support for the children? 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

Yes and no. My brother got together with a girl who had a 9 month old baby. She is 12 now. He's the only father she has ever known. They had a baby together later down the road. (She is 10 now) Guess what happened last year? The mom took off leaving the girls with my brother. Now, legally the oldest isn't my brothers but HE IS HER DADDY! So, should the state take her from my brother and locate her derelict sperm donor? It goes both ways. My brother would give the shirt off his back for her. 

gidget --- 17 years ago -

i voted no. i believe that the court should make the mother search for the bio dad. i have a son that isn't my husbands and if anything were to happen between my husband and i he would be willing to give me extra child support to help with my other son. that is the goodness of his heart not the court system. my son also has 2 dads. my husband and then his bio dad. 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

Yes and no. My brother got together with a girl who had a 9 month old baby. She is 12 now. He's the only father she has ever known. They had a baby together later down the road. (She is 10 now) Guess what happened last year? The mom took off leaving the girls with my brother. Now, legally the oldest isn't my brothers but HE IS HER DADDY! So, should the state take her from my brother and locate her derelict sperm donor? That would be horrible. He raised her as his own even though he KNEW biologically she wasn't. So I think it's different. I doubt if he found out the baby they had together wasn't biologically his he'd feel any different about her either. However if he was deceived about the paternity of his children and found out later, I wouldn't be man hating on him for not paying child support. 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

i voted no. i believe that the court should make the mother search for the bio dad. I don't buy her bullsh1t story she doesn't remember being unfaithful, that's not something you forget. 

B Bright --- 17 years ago -

why would he want to stop paying child support??? i mean...after 16 YEARS of knowing and loving these kids could you just pretty much throw them out of your life?? I can see how he would be pissed that biologically they aren't his, but in a way they are his....i would want the wife to pay me back, but not if it's going to hurt the kids....it's tricky.... maybe wait until the kids are 18 and then make the wife pay him back for "fraud" as they called it.. or make the wife find the biological dad and make him pay....but, i can see how she forgot....i mean....it did say "not long after they were married she found out she was prego" so maybe she was prego before she got married...or even if she wasn't, how many people do you know from 16 years ago??? so it could be really hard to find the bio dad...and do i think the kids should suffer b/c mommy is a floozie???? no.... 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

I would remember someone that I cheated with! 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

I think I would still pay. You can't turn that love off. You know. So I would think he is dead beat if he did, because he then nver truly loved his kids. If someone told me jaxon or kaili weren't mine. I would be devestated but I would still love them unconditionally and want to support them. I can't imagine not loving them. 

whatevergirl ツ --- 17 years ago -

What a sad story. I feel bad for the children, they are the ones who are/will be the most affected by all of this. 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

DNA is such a small part of parentage. If you assume the role of a parent, you ARE the parent. You love them, nurture them, cry with them and support them. 

mommyof2xs1y --- 17 years ago -

So if he doesn't want to continue paying child support because they aren't his, is he going to just stop seeing them and stop being their dad because they didn't come from his dna? you can't have your cake and eat it too. IMO 

☠ PP-Cult Leader/Mind Co --- 17 years ago -

So if he doesn't want to continue paying child support because they aren't his, is he going to just stop seeing them and stop being their dad because they didn't come from his dna? you can't have your cake and eat it too. IMO By severing his support, he will also cut all decision-making ability. He will no longer get to assume the parental role. It protects him as much as people may see otherwise. If he is ordered to pay support he is entitled to certain rights as well. 

whatevergirl ツ --- 17 years ago -

you can't have your cake and eat it too This statement has always made me laugh. If I get a cake of course I want to eat it. What would be the point of getting it then? To stare at it? =0) 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

By severing his support, he will also cut all decision-making ability. He will no longer get to assume the parental role. It protects him as much as people may see otherwise. If he is ordered to pay support he is entitled to certain rights as well. As should be. Like Nicole said, can't have your cake and eat it too! 

Ruthie --- 17 years ago -

This statement has always made me laugh. If I get a cake of course I want to eat it. What would be the point of getting it then? To stare at it? =0) If you have a cake, then you eat it, you don't have it anymore. 

Ange --- 17 years ago -

In this case it would be awful cold-hearted of the dad to abandon kids he's loved for 16 years. I just think this might start a bad precedent and give some shady women a way to make innocent guys pay for kids that aren't their's on the idea that it's best for the kids. 

Moving to Texas --- 17 years ago -

This happened to my husbands cousin... He had 3 kids with his wife but after he later discoverd that the 3 baby wasnt his. Almost no one in the family knows this... He DOESN'T pay child support for the 3rd kid but he DOES take her on his weekends and treats her as if she is his kid... No one knows any diffrently than the court and a few people... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground