I hope you didn't obliterate your account because of me. Constructive critisism is a good thing, it helps bring you to the next level. Take it in stride. No one said you did a terrible job. You are off to a great start, you just need a little tweaking.
I hope in the future you don't take it so personally.
I actually feel bad. She shared a family photo session she took and I gave her suggestions. I also stated my pet peeves. She took down her photos, locked her topic and deleted her account.
Eh some people just get butt hurt too easily. If you can't handle criticism, you shouldn't be putting your stuff out there. If all you want to hear is praise then call your mama...
i thought your post was honest and done with a soft touch - you werent trashing her work but you were pointing out ways for her to take better photos, i noticed the same thing but didnt know how to approach it without seeming harsh
I like your approach to critiques, WEG, but not everyone can take criticism. It's going to be a long, hard road for her if she is going to get so upset when she hears opinions. That's the only way you get better is by hearing what people like and don't like (hence the reason I post my stuff here... I WANT to hear feedback!)
Maybe the OP's subjects didnt like being on PU so she was embarrassed? No clue, but if you post on a public forum you're going to have to take the good with the bad (or suggestions). You put it very nicely WEG.
I don't think it matters whether she asked for it or not. You can't post something on a public forum without expecting people to post their opinions of it - especially the PU.
No Sh!t crystal & thanks for schooling me lol...but if somone is NOT asking for your opinion then don't give it!! Isn't that the PU's perception of being "Snarky"?
i think if you are pimping your work and business name on a paid professional standard then its ok for people to say there were too many shadows, the family never smiled or looked uncomfortable, the photo looked blurred etc
No Sh!t crystal & thanks for schooling me lol...but if somone is NOT asking for your opinion then don't give it!! Isn't that the PU's perception of being "Snarky"?
Perhaps she shouldn't have put it on a public forum then. I dont understand why you are going crazy here. Opinions are going to be posted if you show your work on here. If she just wanted to show the pictures, she could have locked the thread. It doesn't matter if she asked for opinions.
She did my family photos as well and I think she did great.
shes stil learning and they werent that bad (the photos she posted) but not fantastic either (i thought the family looked uncomfortable/never smiled) but the critique wasnt snarky either - people have to start somewhere i guess and again, i dont think WEG's post was mean at all, i mean when is WEG ever outright mean??
She didn't ask for an opinion. I was kind enough to give it. ;0)
I did follow up with a "I know you didn't ask for it...." .
I like pictures. I like looking at peoples work. It's my weird quirk. I also have professionally taken photos for some time, a long time ago. I know a thing or two about a thing or two. I am old after all. I was trying to help her honestly. I would have messages her personally but obviously couldn't since she oblived. Ifigured she would read this thread if I posted it.
Whatevergirl2....I was Sleepless in SoCal...i dont know what happened to my PU account. I dont know how to get it back though. I did appreciate your crit. I also delted my webpage, and just decided to start a fresh-new one, since many ppl said that they did not like the slideshows (which i understand the fact some like going at their own pace) =)
WEG you weren't rude or mean in any way. When someone puts their stuff out as a professional they should expect constructive criticism. I wouldn't worry about it if I were you.
WEG you weren't rude or mean in any way. When someone puts their stuff out as a professional they should expect constructive criticism. I wouldn't worry about it if I were you.
I didnt think there was anything wrong with what WEG said to me. I appreciate it. As for some other people, it was just negative and not constructive.