Wales is trying to change their law so that everyone is automatically and organ donor & you have to "opt out" instead of "opting in" - Do you think we should do this here? Are you an organ donor?
I don't think the government should regulate what you do with your body. I understand they give you an option to "opt out", but automatically signing you up should be considered a violation of your constitutional rights. I am completely pro-organ donation, I myself am one, but I don't think it should be up to the government to decide for you. Besides, I am sure that they wouldn't make it easy for someone to "opt out" with all the paperwork beauracracy they'll carry you up in.
I don't think it should be mandatory, something to "opt-out" of. I think it should stay the way it is. Although I think everyone who gets a drivers license should be intelligent and aware enough to know what they are doing and be able to check a box that says "No", some people just aren't. I would hate to think that someone accidentally didn't check the box and got their organs donated that didn't want to. It took me a while to make a decision as to whether or not I wanted to donate. As of now, I am an organ donor with restrictions.
I don't think the government should regulate what you do with your body. I understand they give you an option to "opt out", but automatically signing you up should be considered a violation of your constitutional rights. I am completely pro-organ donation, I myself am one, but I don't think it should be up to the government to decide for you. Besides, I am sure that they wouldn't make it easy for someone to "opt out" with all the paperwork beauracracy they'll carry you up in.
Well seeing as to how it's not in the US - it's not a violation of your constitutional rights. Besides, is there something in the Constitution that regulates what happens to our dead bodies?
Also, it's really easy to "opt in" so I can't imagine it would be that hard to "opt out."
Well seeing as to how it's not in the US - it's not a violation of your constitutional rights. Besides, is there something in the Constitution that regulates what happens to our dead bodies?
I'm speaking as though it WERE a practice in the US, if they ever decide need be.
I can't help but think if you're an organ donor, would they try as hard to save your life, As they would if you wern't?
Thats the reservation many people have. I have no idea if thats the case but I am not afraid of death. I just hope that my death will change someone elses life.
people should have a say in what happenes to their bodies no matter what. in even some religions you are not to desecrate(sp) your body dead or alive so it really touches on the freedoms we are entitl
For all of the people who are saying that someone shouldn't be forced to do something - You aren't being forced. It's an option. You just have to choose that option. Not arguing with anyone - I don't believe that anyone's view on this are "wrong".
Then why change the current policy? To me, it seems like a passive aggressive way to get some to donate organs - like I stated before, I wouldn't be surprised if there was a bureaucratic whirlwind of bs paperwork to choose to "opt-out".
Like maybe before the age of 18, it's up to your parents. When you get a new Driver's License when you turn 18, then you have to make the decision on your own. As for a John Doe - maybe since it's an "opt out" program, they would automatically do it.. or automatically not? Who knows?
im also an organ donor.. my husband says i shouldnt be cause if i was to ever be in an accident and they would see my id they wouldnt save me and let me die for my organs.. i swear hes so full of sh!!t sometimes..
Then why change the current policy? To me, it seems like a passive aggressive way to get some to donate organs - like I stated before, I wouldn't be surprised if there was a bureaucratic whirlwind of bs paperwork to choose to "opt-out".
Because people are dying because of the lack of donors.
And just assume there isn't a ton of paperwork. Just assume it's a form you fill out to fax to someone.
I don't think it should be mandatory because their are some people (myself being one) who can not donate organs or blood for that matter due to health problems.
Because people are dying because of the lack of donors.
I am completely aware of this. But one's needs should never superceed the beliefs or choices of another. I am an organ donor, because essentially, if I'm gone, it won't be my biggest concern on what happens to my body. Others have differing beliefs and shouldn't have to go through a process to opt out.
I am completely aware of this. But one's needs should never superceed the beliefs or choices of another. I am an organ donor, because essentially, if I'm gone, it won't be my biggest concern on what happens to my body. Others have differing beliefs and shouldn't have to go through a process to opt out.
They are not taking away the ability to CHOOSE - they are simply streamlining and making it to where you choose NOT TO instead of TO. LOL. You keep saying that it's a "process" to opt out - but Wales may have a system in mind where it's just really simple and you provide your SS# number and fill out a form.
They are not taking away the ability to CHOOSE - they are simply streamlining and making it to where you choose NOT TO instead of TO. LOL. You keep saying that it's a "process" to opt out - but Wales may have a system in mind where it's just really simple and you provide your SS# number and fill out a form.
I see a change of policy in such a manner would be one more baby step to governing a person's body. There may be a choice, but you should never have to opt out, you should be assumed opt out until you check the box at the DMV.
I see a change of policy in such a manner would be one more baby step to governing a person's body. There may be a choice, but you should never have to opt out, you should be assumed opt out until you check the box at the DMV.
I agree with you. I also think that by making it an automatic "opt-in", the government is hoping that people will overlook the fact that they are automatically enrolled and there will be more organs donated based on neglect.
And I absolutely do not think that children should automatically enrolled and then when they are 18 get a choice. I personally think that even if this were implemented in the US, the exception should be children and that they would be opted out until the age of 18 when they could make the conscious decision to opt out.
And I absolutely do not think that children should automatically enrolled and then when they are 18 get a choice. I personally think that even if this were implemented in the US, the exception should be children and that they would be opted out until the age of 18 when they could make the conscious decision to opt out.
Just for the record, I said it should be up to the parents before the age of 18 - not that they should automatically be enrolled in the program.
I can't help but think if you're an organ donor, would they try as hard to save your life, As they would if you wern't?
As someone who has worked a code in the er.....this is the LAST thing we are thinking about when someone comes in off that ambulance. Saving a life is always first. It's only as things pass from bad to worse when organs begin being discussed.