H.S., a Silsbee student, reported being raped in 2008 by Rakheem Bolton, a fellow student and athletic star, with the help of two of his friends. In the end, Bolton recently ended up getting off without serving any jail time by pleading guilty to a lesser assault charge, spending two years on probation, doing community service, paying a fine, and attending anger management courses. Hardly seems like an adequate punishment, but it's unfortunately not uncommon for attackers to bargain down their charges. What really gets the blood boiling is how the students' high school treated the victim when the rape charge was levied.
Bolton was set to be on the school's varsity basketball team, and they couldn't risk losing by barring him from playing for a silly thing like a rape charge. That could impact their chances at winning. Who cares about the traumatic impact it would have an a cheerleader who needed to vocally support a team including her rapist?
But H.S. fulfilled her role as a cheerleader, participating in all the cheers for the team as a group. She simply refused to shout the first name of the man who assaulted her when he stood up alone to make free throws. It seems like she was being more than accommodating, when an student athlete facing trial on rape charges most likely should have been suspended from the team, even if his presence wasn't a source of immediate distress to his victim in her position as cheerleader. In a display of extreme disrespect for a rape survivor and disregard for her well-being, school officials insisted that H.S. had to scream "Rakheem" with the rest of the cheerleaders, or she'd be kicked off the squad.Not only that, Caroline Heldman reports on Ms. Magazine's blog that school officials pushed H.S. "to keep a low profile, such as avoiding the school cafeteria and not taking part in homecoming activities." As though she should somehow be ashamed for having been raped and brought charges against her attacker. Where exactly was she supposed to eat so as to not cause discomfort to the star athlete? H.S. also refused to take this offensive "advice."
H.S. sued her school district for removing her from the cheerleading squad. In an absurd court ruling, the 5th U.S. Circuit of Appeals decided to uphold the school's decision, claiming that a cheerleader was but a "mouthpiece" for a school to use to "disseminate speech namely, support for its athletic teams." Her silence apparently "constituted substantial interference with the work of the school because, as a cheerleader, H.S. was at the basketball game for the purpose of cheering, a position she undertook voluntarily." Well, I'm sure H.S. never expected to be "volunteering" to cheer for someone who had assaulted her. And the idea that just being silent during Bolton's free throws, a barely noticeable act, was "substantial interference with the work of the school" um, we're talking extracurricular sports, not classroom disruption makes little sense.
Tell Silsbee officials that this is no way to treat rape victims, and insist that they publicly issue an apology to H.S. immediately. Furthermore, tell them to instate a policy outlining appropriate treatment of sexual assault survivors, which does not put the onus on the victim to ensure smooth interactions at the school.
So he didn't get found guilty of rape, but pleaded out to another charge in 2008. Now they both attend the same school at which he plays ball and she cheers? So is he not supposed to go on with his life? She knew he played on the team, why join the squad?
He pleaded guilty to assaulting her. Therefore he is a criminal. I don't care whether or not he goes on with his life. I care about school officials who put their wants of winning a sports game over concern for the victim. Her life should go on without ever having to say the name of her attacker. I find it disgusting that school officials can overlook his crime of assault. However, they cannot overlook her not saying his name.
Doosh - He should have been suspended from school in the first place. He should not have been allowed back on the team. But the fact that he was allowed to stay in school and on the team isn't bad enough, they want to FORCE the cheerleader to scream his name...Sure, I could understand kicking her off the team if she wasn't cheering at all while he played, but she just doesn't want to specifically cheer for him....to scream his name. She gets kicked off the team for something so small...yet he gets to go on living his life with no consequences from the school? That is what I don't like about it.
He pleaded guilty to assaulting her. Therefore he is a criminal. I don't care whether or not he goes on with his life. I care about school officials who put their wants of winning a sports game over concern for the victim. Her life should go on without ever having to say the name of her attacker. I find it disgusting that school officials can overlook his crime of assault. However, they cannot overlook her not saying his name.
Unless I read that wrong, he pled to an assault charge. That could be the same as you get charged with for getting in a fight. Had he been convicted of sexual assault or sexual battery, I'd agree with you wholeheartedly, but I didn't get that from that article. Her attorney or the DA accepted a lesser plea. Why? If he raped her, why settle for anything less than something that would convict him of being a sexual offender? The reason is that there was more than likely not enough evidence to convict him, so the prosecutor settled for a lesser charge since "something is better than nothing". He got punished for the crime that he pled guilty to, did his time and repaid his debt to society. He is moving on. She chose to be on a squad that would cheer for the team that he is playing for. If she can not fulfill her obligations, then she doesn't need to be on that squad.
I didn't write anywhere that he was convicted of a sexual assault. I understand he pleaded down to a lesser charge. She is the victim of an assault. He is a convicted criminal. I am disgusted with school officials overlooking his conviction allowing him to continue to be part of a team. Yet, they cannot overlook her not saying his name after he was convicted of assaulting her.
This will just have to be the 196th (rough estimate) subject we disagree on.
I didn't write anywhere that he was convicted of a sexual assault. I understand he pleaded down to a lesser charge. She is the victim of an assault. He is a convicted criminal. I am disgusted with school officials overlooking his conviction allowing him to continue to be part of a team. Yet, they cannot overlook her not saying his name after he was convicted of assaulting her.
Was he convicted of a felony or misdemeanor? There is only so much the school can do based on the conviction. Had they banned him from playing, they could be held liable for that too. It's a double edged sword really. There is no winning side here.
On one hand I feel bad for her. Do I think she should of been kicked off for not cheering his name? No. Whoopee!
But on the other hand you can't tell me there aren't other schools she could of went to. YES, I know she shouldn't HAVE to switch schools but IMO if he wasn't going to I would have.
On one hand I feel bad for her. Do I think she should of been kicked off for not cheering his name? No. Whoopee!
But on the other hand you can't tell me there aren't other schools she could of went to. YES, I know she shouldn't HAVE to switch schools but IMO if he wasn't going to I would have.
But on the other hand you can't tell me there aren't other schools she could of went to. YES, I know she shouldn't HAVE to switch schools but IMO if he wasn't going to I would have.
Where are the other schools located they she should switch too? What is the percentage of their students who are accepted into 4 year institutions? There are a lot of factors to consider when leaving one's school.
Where are the other schools located they she should switch too? What is the percentage of their students who are accepted into 4 year institutions? There are a lot of factors to consider when leaving one's school.
I was just pointing out she had other options. I'm not agreeing with what the school did and I'm not agreeing with him even being back at the school.
I was just pointing out she had other options. I'm not agreeing with what the school did and I'm not agreeing with him even being back at the school.
What were her options? Are you familar with the area she lives in? Hell, maybe she should've just stayed locked up in the house & home schooled. Damn her for coming forward and reporting a crime!
Where are the other schools located they she should switch too? What is the percentage of their students who are accepted into 4 year institutions? There are a lot of factors to consider when leaving one's school.
What were her options? Are you familar with the area she lives in? Hell, maybe she should've just stayed locked up in the house & home schooled. Damn her for coming forward and reporting a crime!
We don't know that she had "no options", just like you don't know that she didn't have "tons of options". We don't know the whole story.
I feel bad for her. Rape is no joke and shouldn't be taken lightly.
I didn't notice in the article, but was she on the cheer team before this incident occurred? Either way, this "boy" stripped her of plenty of things when he decided to rape her, why should she give up something else she wanted to pursue and "give in" to what this guy has done once more? The school should have at least respected her wishes not to cheer for him. That's a disgusting request, if you ask me.
Kariane - She could have changed schools, but she didn't want to change. From the way this article sounds, she even did cheer for the team as a whole ....as in "GO BULLDOGS...BEAT THE TIGERS." She just didn't want to specifically say "GO RAHKEEM"....should she have been kicked off the team for choosing not to say one word? One pesons name? I think thats a load of bull...even if she just didn't like the guy and he never did anything to her...to get kicked off for not saying his name??? Honestly, I want to know how they knew she wasn't saying his name? I mean, did she protest and walk out of the squads cheering post when he went to shoot free throws? Was someone sitting there right beside her (like the principal) to make sure she said his name? If she would have just stood there quietly nobody would really know if she was screaming it or not.
If she tried to walk off the cheering post because he was up to shoot then I could understand them kicking her off, but for just not saying his name??? A bit overly dramatic I think...
I don't like that victims have to change their lives simply because if they don't, their life only seems to get 10x harder. He also had options, rape or don't rape. He decided to and STILL the girl gets kicked off the squad? I don't think so.
a coiple of guys from my highschool video taped one of then having sex with her while the other one hid in a closet then showed it to all the guys in the field house. Both boys were expelled from the DISTRICT not just the school. And she continued going to our h.s but would eat her lunches in the office because she was embarrassed...i think every school handles things differently. In my opinion the school should've expelled him.
oh and wanna know something about the guys that did that at my highschool? Ones here at camp pendleton and ones in the army.
I don't like that victims have to change their lives simply because if they don't, their life only seems to get 10x harder. He also had options, rape or don't rape. He decided to and STILL the girl gets kicked off the squad? I don't think so.
Who ever said he raped her? He was accused of it, that's as far as it went.
amandanicole - I think the difference in your story and this one is that there was video. That is hardcore evidence. I'm assuming since he pleaded guilty to a lesser charge that they didn't have enough evidence to get him with rape (like doosh mentioned earlier)...It was most likely a "he said, she said" deal so they got him with less...