Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

MAC Controversy

who's talking here?

Mrs Patch 3
Ms-V 1
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 1
sofaa 1
El Doosho 3
BitBit 1
LakerGirl 1
Life expansions 2
Jay Elle 1
whatevergirlツ 6
Cellulite City 8
APPLE 4
Purple 1
Ha 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

APPLE --- 16 years ago -

Has anyone read about this? What is your view on it? The Rodarte collection. 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

Read what? LOL! 

APPLE --- 16 years ago -

linky 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

I think someone made a PR blunder. However, some women's groups will benefit from it.

I hope they reintroduce the colors in future collections. 

Purple --- 16 years ago -

I have no idea what to think. This is sad. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

This person said it all for me:

"i'm not a die-hard mac fan, but i'm definitely going to pass on this one. a lot of people say, "who cares? it's just makeup." but it isn't JUST makeup when you capitalize on other people's horrific realities.

are people going to say "who cares? it's just makeup" if mac releases a 9/11 inspired collection? or how about an eyeshadow called "auschwitz?" or a lipstick called "blood diamond?"

just because the situation in juarez isn't much talked about, doesn't make it less important. if anything good has come out of this hoopla, it's that more people are now informed of the women of juarez. but it doesn't take away from the fact that this collection was done in BAD FORM."

and i agree, the statement mac made reeks of "after-thought." they should've thought of this in the first place! 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

Estee Lauder isn't the most sensitive of companies.

Bwhahahahahahahaha... 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

Just another thing for people to complain about. I think people are entirely too sensitive and read way to into things! People can't even fart nowadays without being sued for stinking up your air. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

SO what were these offensive names?? I'm just curious. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Just another thing for people to complain about. I think people are entirely too sensitive and read way too into things! People can't even fart nowadays without being sued for stinking up your air.


If people could, I'd be poor. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

Original Post:

There has been much buzz over the controversy of M.A.C.'s Rodarte collection and the designer's questionable inspiration of a little town in Mexico called Juarez. The history of Juarez was news to me and I was unfamiliar with the background of the town until I read it on Vex in The City. I had heard about the collaboration between M.A.C. and the Rodarte sister designers, Laura and Kate Mullevy, launching this Fall but didn't clue into the controversy that surrounds it.


Juarez, known as a factory town in Mexico, is notorious for the disappearance of hundreds of women between the ages of 12 and 22 who have been raped and murdered on their way to work, with little help from the police leaving most cases unsolved. It's disturbing and horrific, leaving me more sad than inspired.


It's difficult to look at this campaign shot of a ghostly model who is rail thin, and with eyes that stare back at you with nothing but emptiness. I can't look at her without getting goose bumps and not in the good way. Seeing this picture does not make me want to run out and buy the collection. And after reading some of the names of the products, all I could think was "Really??". No, I will not be swiping on my shadow called "Sleepwalker" only to be reminded of the women and children who were raped and murdered for this "inspiration".


Either M.A.C. and the Rodarte designers are absolutely insensitive or this is all apart of a brilliant marketing plan to make M.A.C. look like heroes, making this a sell-out collection. Style List almost seems to sugar coat the situation praising M.A.C. for issuing a statement saying a portion of the proceeds from the collection will go to those in need in Juarez. Fabulous, now that sh*t has hit the fan. Was the real purpose of the collection to recognize the hardships of these women and to be inspire us M.A.C. addicts to help? Really. I think these women have been exploited enough. Sometimes bad publicity is just bad publicity. 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

Lipstick ($14.00 U.S. / $16.50 CDN)
Ghost Town Sheer white with white, gold and green pearlized pigment (Frost) (Limited Edition)
Rose State Mid-tone blue pink (Lustre) (Limited Edition)
Sleepless Light grey taupe (Frost) (Limited Edition)
Lipglass ($18.00 U.S. / $21.50 CDN)
Rodarte Pale creamy pink with layers of sparkling white, mint, and pink (Limited Edition)
del Norte Light creamy violet with layers of sheer sparkling taupe, pink and grey (Limited Edition)
Lip Erase ($16.00 U.S. / $19.00 CDN)
Pale Flesh tone NC 27 Shade (Matte) (PRO)
Mineralize Eyeshadow ($19.50 U.S. / $23.50 CDN)
Bordertown Black with red, pale blue, and silver veining (Frost) (Limited Edition)
Sleepwalker Beige with copper, pale blue and pale pink veining (Frost) (Limited Edition)
Pigment ($19.50 U.S. / $23.50 CDN)
White Gold White pearl with gold duochrome (PRO)
Kitschmas Shimmering pink/mauve (Permanent)
Mauvement Cool taupe with gold pearl (Limited Edition) (Repromote from Rushmetal, Overrich)
Badlands Mid-tone shimmer beige brown (Limited Edition)
Chromographic Pencil ($14.50 U.S. / $17.50 CDN)
NW25/NC30 Flesh tone NW25/NC30 shade (Matte) (PRO)
Beauty Powder ($25.00 U.S. / $30.00 CDN)
Softly Drifting Pale neutral white-ish pink with soft gold pearl (Limited Edition)
Blush ($18.50 U.S./$22.00 CDN)
Quinceanera Shimmery mid-tone blue pink (Limited Edition)
Nail Lacquer ($12.00 U.S. / $14.50 CDN)
Juarez Bright opal pink (Frost) (Limited Edition)
Factory Light opal mint (Frost) (Limited Edition) 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

There is no bad publicity unless you are Nixon, Mel Gibson and R. Kelly.

Oh and I forgot Roman Polasky... 

Life expansions --- 16 years ago -

Just another thing for people to complain about. I think people are entirely too sensitive and read way too into things! People can't even fart nowadays without being sued for stinking up your air.

lol...I agree I love MAC.. and I still will be purchasing it to 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

The names are not bad or disrespectful. Am I missing something?

I could understand:

lipstick was named Ripped Hymen
pale pink eyeshadow Virgin No More
rust blush Bruised Thighs
black shadow Dead & Missing
blue nail police Found Floating

Hey but none of my family or friends were the victims. 

APPLE --- 16 years ago -

The names are not bad or disrespectful. Am I missing something?

I could understand:

lipstick was named Ripped Hymen
pale pink eyeshadow Virgin No Morerust blush Bruised Thighsblack shadow Dead & Missingblue nail police Found Floating
I agree. I think people read too much into it. MAC always has funky names for their products. But so far from what I read they will not be releasing the collection. 

Life expansions --- 16 years ago -

I agree. I think people read too much into it. MAC always has funky names for their products. But so far from what I read they will not be releasing the collection.

agree 

Ms-V --- 16 years ago -

I knew a girl raped and killed in Juarez. I do find it offensive. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

I don't find it offensive, but I find it in poor taste. Personally someone in marketing f*cked up. That is all. 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

I knew a girl raped and killed in Juarez. I do find it offensive.

So the make up raped and killed your friend?

Just as silly as being mad they made a line in honor of the women there. 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

So the make up raped and killed your friend?

Just as silly as being mad they made a line in honor of the women there.


I don't think that was her point. 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

Look at all the plubicity it has gotten. How many women now know of the women of Juarez. Sometimes it takes things of this scale to get the attention these situations need for change. 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

I don't think that was her point.

Obviously. 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

Obviously.

You are the one who wrote it. LMAO. I knew about the women of Juarez for quite some time now. It's a really sad situation for the people there and their families & friends.

Juarez has received national attention.

I did not know about the upcoming/now sidelined MAC collection until this thread. Not only is the PU entertainment but I usually learn something every other day. 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

So... Rodarte was inspired by this town? He's a pretty well known designer. I'm curious what he has to say. I would think he knew about the towns history but maybe not? 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

I knew about the women of Juarez for quite some time now. It's a really sad situation of the people there and their families & friends.

Juarez has received national attention.


Yeppers, they didn't need MAC to do it for them, but MAC needed the controversy to promote their product.

Anyway, wasn't Salma Hayek making a movie about the women of Juarez or was it Angelina Jolie? Do you know CC? 

APPLE --- 16 years ago -

I knew a girl raped and killed in Juarez. I do find it offensive.
What about it do you find offensive? 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

Nonetheless I think some people have a hard time with the stone cold truth. I dont mind the names because I believe them to be their truth. See I lack the sugar coating factor. When I say things they tend to be straight to the point. I believe the line to be the same and maybe that is why I think its fine with me. 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

Jennifer Lopez has been pegged for it. I don't know about the other women.

I adore Salma Hayek and Angelina Jolie! 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

Oh wow. My friend actually works in MAC PR. I'll have to ask her about this. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground