Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Assisted Suicide

who's talking here?

Mrs. blah 1
San Antonio Bound 1
Going - Going - GONE! 4
Lavender is Good 3
MissMaggy 2
El Doosho 4
Spork Fight 8
Colonel LizZoo 2
☼J∃ηиi 1
Melissa 1
Happygolucky 6
Perfectly Imperfect 1
Green Chick 1
SierraFoxtrot 1
Sei Con Me 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Happygolucky --- 16 years ago -

I have to do a research paper on assisted suicide and wanted to see how people really feel about it.

My instructor told us to try to get opinions on our topic from people outside our normal circle friends. That is when this board came to mind. Although I am mainly a lurker on this site (i guess I don’t have too much to say), I do enjoy the passion in your points that some of you display on certain subject.

As right now I am going to hold off on disclosing if I am writing for or against assisted suicide. :) After several post I will reveal then stand that I am taking. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

I am all for it. I think nobody should have more control over my own life than me. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

what doosho said. 

Happygolucky --- 16 years ago -

Thanks El Doosho! 

SierraFoxtrot --- 16 years ago -

I agree with it. I agree with people being in control of their own bodies and lives. If someone has a set amount of time to live and they are so uncomfortable with the way they feel, they are in so much pain, I believe they should have the right to put an end to their suffering. 

☼J∃ηиi --- 16 years ago -

Yeah I don't think its a bad thing in certain circumstances. I'm thinking old people who are in so much pain or already terminal patients that just want to end it now. At least they can die knowing they weren't powerless over their own life and the peace will come that much sooner. 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 16 years ago -

If someone wants to kill themself then that's their decision. No need to enlist the help of others. I don't care how miserable or in pain someone is, they need to be creative in doing it themselves. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

id rather have a doctor- someone who knew how to cease life painlessly, verses dity where you clumsily try to figure it out, and probably put your self in more pain than before... 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

I agree that if someone wants to kill themselves, then fine. No one should be allowed to help though. Too many variables. What if the person changes their mind and has no way to stop it? What if it is used to cover up murder? I just don't see any way that assisted suicide could ever be allowed without risking any of the things that could come along with it. 

Mrs. blah --- 16 years ago -

I think people who are dying or very sick and will never get better should be allowed to go to their doctor and have their doctor help them in their suicide 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

if assisted suicide was legal, it would cut down those variables :) paper work, signatures verifying that the person wanted it etc... 

Happygolucky --- 16 years ago -

Since I have begun my research one of the oddest reason against assisted suicide I have came across is the fact that the medical industry would loose money. 

MissMaggy --- 16 years ago -

i think it's also very important to look at the full spectrum. assisted suicide can range from one person killing another, to helping them get what they need to kill themselves, to even just knowing someone wants to and not saying anything about it. I think there are a lot of special circumstances in each case and there is no "it's okay" or "it's not okay" 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

if assisted suicide was legal, it would cut down those variables :) paper work, signatures verifying that the person wanted it etc...

Yes, but... if someone else is killing you, you give up that moment at the end to change your mind. If you change your mind and they don't realize or worse, figure it's better that way anyway, then it becomes murder.

Of course this all depends on what we are defining assisted suicide as. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

i think the whole change your mind thing is garbage.. when you are old,and going to die, and in pain, i think their mind is made up... its the young ones who are upset cause their boyfriend broke up with them who are the ones who change their minds.. 

Green Chick --- 16 years ago -

What if it is used to cover up murder? I just don't see any way that assisted suicide could ever be allowed without risking any of the things that could come along with it.

I think this is a great point. People would start using it to their advantage 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

What if it is used to cover up murder? I just don't see any way that assisted suicide could ever be allowed without risking any of the things that could come along with it.

I think this is a great point. People would start using it to their advantage


If assisted suicide was legal and monitored, how could it be used to cover up a murder? 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

think the whole change your mind thing is garbage.. when you are old,and going to die, and in pain, i think their mind is made up... its the young ones who are upset cause their boyfriend broke up with them who are the ones who change their minds..


Exactly, Sarcasm. People who are in that much pain and are terminal deserve an option rather than wasting away begging for someone to help end it all. We put animals down when they get old and are in pain or have a painful, terminal disease because "it's more humane" but it isn't really. We don't allow the elderly folks dying slowly and painfully or those who are dying of a very painful cancer to choose to have a doctor end it all. If I wind up in a situation where I'm old, terminal, and in a lot of pain, I want someone to treat me like an animal...put me down, because it's the "humane" thing to do. 

Happygolucky --- 16 years ago -

I am for assisted suicide for the terminally ill, anyone with life threatening illness or any serious health related problem that the health professionals feel that they cannot improve the quality of life for. I don’t feel that I have to right to tell someone in horrible pain that they must suffer being that them wanting to die is against any belief I might have. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

lol my mil already told me when she gets old and decrepit to hit her upside the head with a frying pan... 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 16 years ago -

If assisted suicide was legal and monitored, how could it be used to cover up a murder?

That again would come to, "What's your definition of assisted suicide."

Having a friend give you a bottle of sleeping pills knowing what the persons intentions are is technically still assisted suicide. It's illegal but still. Can't exactly regulate that.

That's exactly why I said if someone wants to kill themselves go ahead but get creative with it and do it yourself. Hmm maybe billboards will be made saying, "Cut down the road NOT across the street!" 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

My Grandmother died a long, slow, and painful death. For the last 3 years of her life she could barely breathe even though she was on oxygen 24 hours a day, I know it was incredibly hard for her but she treasured every moment of the time she had with us.

And I don't think it is garbage that someone might change their mind. When someone is terminally ill and in pain, they are more likely to be depressed. A depressed person might think they'd like to end it all, but they might also change their mind at the last minute. It might not happen often, but the possibility of it happening is enough for me.

I would be supportive of a method set up whereby a person was given the tools they needed to painlessly end it themselves under supervised conditions, but I would never support another person being allowed to be involved. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -


Having a friend give you a bottle of sleeping pills knowing what the persons intentions are is technically still assisted suicide. It's illegal but still. Can't exactly regulate that.

That's exactly why I said if someone wants to kill themselves go ahead but get creative with it and do it yourself. Hmm maybe billboards will be made saying, "Cut down the road NOT across the street!"


I'm using my well developed Spidey Senses and assuming that the OP is referring to "Professional Medical Assistance" being that she is doing a research paper. 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 16 years ago -

Exactly, Sarcasm. People who are in that much pain and are terminal deserve an option rather than wasting away begging for someone to help end it all. We put animals down when they get old and are in pain or have a painful, terminal disease because "it's more humane" but it isn't really. We don't allow the elderly folks dying slowly and painfully or those who are dying of a very painful cancer to choose to have a doctor end it all. If I wind up in a situation where I'm old, terminal, and in a lot of pain, I want someone to treat me like an animal...put me down, because it's the "humane" thing to do

They already have other options! Pills and alcohol. Gun to the head. Hanging themselves. Turn the gas on the stove on. Turn your car on in the garage while the garage door is closed. Cyt their wrist. Go buy some meth and OD. Really? There are a million ways to kill your self. The only thing assisted suiced per doctor would do is make it so it doesn't sound as bad. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

i would if said person was a doctor.. and i am not one to prolong the inevitable.. if i were ever a vegetable, or terminally ill, get it over with, so my fam can move on... sitting by a bedside, counting down the days, is a miserable way to live, and i wouldnt wan t that for my fam- i would want them to remember the good times when i was healthy. 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 16 years ago -

I'm using my well developed Spidey Senses and assuming that the OP is referring to "Professional Medical Assistance" being that she is doing a research paper.

But that's the problem. There are so many different definitions for it. 

Happygolucky --- 16 years ago -

I watched a documentary this week on some that went to Europe with the intent to die. However this person was to week to really take part in their own death.

The person who was assisting held a cup with a straw up to the person’s mouth so they could drink the medicine. This was to put the person to sleep. Before he dosed off the person assisting placed the clicker in the person’s mouth to bit down on to turn of a machine that they were on. By law the entire process was filmed, including the person stating that they wanted to end their life. After the person died, they called in officials to check over everything to ensure that is was an assisted suicide & not murder. During the entire time the spouse was there and was a witness.

Does this change anyone’s thoughts?

By the way, thanks for all the great input! 

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

I am for it. I used to work in a nursing home and watched people's health decline. I always said that I would never want to suffer. I also seen my grandma suffer and it was the most painful thing. I think you should be able to pick when you go. 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

They already have other options! Pills and alcohol. Gun to the head. Hanging themselves. Turn the gas on the stove on. Turn your car on in the garage while the garage door is closed. Cyt their wrist. Go buy some meth and OD. Really? There are a million ways to kill your self. The only thing assisted suiced per doctor would do is make it so it doesn't sound as bad. 

Except that many of them are immobile. Do you think that people who are in that much pain are able to drive around to score meth? lol Or perhaps they want a sure death. A gun to the head doesn't always kill you, pills and alcohol don't either...especially when you're that sick and there is usually someone very nearby (a nurse or family members). A doctor assisted suicide is going to be a sure death. So why should they have to "get creative" to kill themselves when they are already in pain and terminal? Why not give them some dignity in their choice? 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

So why should they have to "get creative" to kill themselves when they are already in pain and terminal? Why not give them some dignity in their choice?



well said 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground