Are you in favor of this or not?
DADT has resulted in the discharges of over 13k military members, only 20% of which were found to have committed a homosexual act. The President would like openly gay individuals to be allowed to serve.
Have any of you heard of Lt. Dan Choi?
Have any of you heard of Lt. Dan Choi?
yes, he's been on anderson cooper 360 a few times and i saw him on it.
my personal thoughts on repealing it: great! people should be free to do whatever they want, no matter their race/sex/religion/sexual preference.
I'm for it, but is it really safe for them to be OPENLY gay in the military?
In other jobs, you don't disclose your sexual orientation. So why the Military?
While I am all for allowing homosexuals to openly serve, I do think that there is a high risk this will put people in physical danger brought on by people who are either homophobic or closet homosexuals who do not wish to be "outed." I would like to think that if you are already working with people in a tight knit environment, it should not come as a surprise if they are indeed of a certain sexual preference, and therefore it have no special importance, but then again, I live in the real world where things can get ugly. I would hate for this to get ug;y for some people because who knows what dangers close mindedness can cause.
I am... for gay marriage.. but against gays in the military. It seems hateful and I am anything but.. I have LOTS of gay friends.. but it seems to me like it doesn't promote unit/company/battalion cohesion.
I think repealing it as a policy is the right thing to do because it is discriminatory. However, I think for the service member's safety, it's still probably best to keep it to themselves.
For some people, the hate runs so deep and perhaps they would not be there for someone in combat, or give them the proper training beforehand simply because that person is openly gay.
I would like for openly gay military members to be allowed to serve. I read the letter Lt. Choi wrote to the President and it moved me. Part of it said:
"As an infantry officer, I am not accustomed to begging. But I beg you today: Do not fire me. Do not fire me because my soldiers are more than a unit or a fighting force - we are a family and we support each other. We should not learn that honesty and courage leads to punishment and insult. Their professionalism should not be rewarded with losing their leader."
I did a persuasive speech on this topic. No other employer in our nation is allowed to discriminate against a willing and able worker on the basis of sexual preference other than the US Military. Gays are allowed to serve openly in the Israeli Army which is a close knit combat focused fighting force just like ours.
I'm for it and so is my husband. But he's fine with it unless someone tried to get a little to friendly, then it's a no-go. One of his good friends he fought in OIF2 with was gay. He never made a move on anyone and he fought just as hard as all the straight guys.
Our thinking is everyone bleeds red. What else should matter?
ETA: I don't think you should be wearing a rainbow sticker on your ass or anything though lol
I'm for it, but is it really safe for them to be OPENLY gay in the military?
In other jobs, you don't disclose your sexual orientation. So why the Military?
It's not about that, it's about that with DADT you are not allowed to be gay anywhere outside your own head ever. 80% of those 13,ooo+ had never committed a sexual act, someone somewhere just found out they were gay. In one case a decorated Lt. Col. was accused of a crime and to exonerate himself he had to admit that he was gay. He was discharged.
While I am all for allowing homosexuals to openly serve, I do think that there is a high risk this will put people in physical danger brought on by people who are either homophobic or closet homosexuals who do not wish to be "outed." I would like to think that if you are already working with people in a tight knit environment, it should not come as a surprise if they are indeed of a certain sexual preference, and therefore it have no special importance, but then again, I live in the real world where things can get ugly. I would hate for this to get ug;y for some people because who knows what dangers close mindedness can cause.
Close mindedness occurs in all professions, not just the military. Why is the military the only profession in which it is okay? Additionally studies of military members who have served with a comrade they knew to be gay showed that the majority said it did not hurt unit morale or cohesion.
It's not about that, it's about that with DADT you are not allowed to be gay anywhere outside your own head ever. 80% of those 13,ooo+ had never committed a sexual act, someone somewhere just found out they were gay. In one case a decorated Lt. Col. was accused of a crime and to exonerate himself he had to admit that he was gay. He was discharged.
That's another issue.
In one case a decorated Lt. Col. was accused of a crime and to exonerate himself he had to admit that he was gay. He was discharged.
Then so be it. He knew about DADT and went against the order.
This is a tough one for me. In theory, I'm for it because I believe that any form of discrimination is wrong.
However, Mrs. Patch brought up my worst fears about repealing DADT. The military doesn't have the best track record when it comes to hate crimes against homosexuals.
Close mindedness occurs in all professions, not just the military. Why is the military the only profession in which it is okay? Additionally studies of military members who have served with a comrade they new to be gay showed that the majority said it did not hurt unit morale or cohesion.
Please show me where I said closed mindedness is ok as in acceptable? I said it is to be feared because closed mindedness can very easily lead to the demise of those who would serve openly. And as for your second point, you seem to just have reiterated what I stated: I would like to think that if you are already working with people in a tight knit environment, it should not come as a surprise if they are indeed of a certain sexual preference, and therefore it have no special importance
That's another issue.
I don't believe so. It appears to be the obvious result of the DADT policy. The number of discharges actually rose dramatically after it was put into place. Discharges peaked in August 2001, but magically lessened to a degree after 9/11.
Please show me where I said closed mindedness is ok as in acceptable?
I never said you did, I was just sharing my thoughts. Your posts just prompted those thoughts.
Okay.. I'm actually having a really hard time finding my stance on this issue.
I am also. I want to support it....but, I'm just not sure I do.
hate crimes against homosexuals.
See, I don't think hate crimes are my only issue. To me, it seems messy to have openly gay men being arranged in barracks, on deployments, you know? Would gay men be put with other gay men, with a straight male? With a female? I don't know...I believe they should have equal rights and opportunities, but I can't see it going very smoothly.
I never said you did, I was just sharing my thoughts. Your posts just prompted those thoughts.
The way you worded your sentence suggested I was stating it was acceptable.
It is not, but I do think that leading the lamb to the lions den is going to cause some serious issues. So long as the military is prepared to deal with those issues, then they should repeal because it is discriminatory.
I think fear of the unknown is a powerful thing, but I also think men and women in uniform are given less credit than they deserve when it comes to interacting with homosexuals. I mean, they are adults Maybe everything would be alright.....
If the ban is lifted, there will be a lot of friendly fire going on.
People from all over the U.S. join the military. And being gay is not openly acceptable across the board.
I'm open minded & I do accept homosexuality. But the Military is a different world.