First, this does not involve me or my animals, it's a situation I heard about and wanted opinions.
If you have a small breed dog get under a fence or through a hole in a fence (fence should be shared property of small breed dog owner and the owner of the property large breed dog owner rents from) into the yard of a large breed dog and the small breed dog ends up dead, is the large breed dog's owner at fault? The large breed dog has not previously shown aggression like this and no one was there to see what happened so it is only guesswork as to what happened after the small breed dog entered the large breed dog's yard.
If a small dog gets into my yard, and my stupid big dog kills it because he thinks its an electric chew-toy, the large dog should not be at fault. Just like if someone broke into my house and my dog ate them, again, not my fault LOL
If my dog got OUT and hurt someone or their dog, my fault.
I do not think the large breed dog and/or it's owner is at fault. The little guy got out of his area and wandered into an area he shouldn't have been in. Sad for him and the family but it is more their fault for not making sure the fence was secure.
Like this was my situation. My dog got into our neighbors yard, bc my neighbor's dog started digging into our yard.. my dog got through. He is a great dane and mine is a shih tzu, they played and both were fine.. but had something happened to my dog, I would probably have been furious. My dogs dont dig.
So more details are needed to your story IMO.
I do not think the large breed dog and/or it's owner is at fault. The little guy got out of his area and wandered into an area he shouldn't have been in. Sad for him and the family but it is more their fault for not making sure the fence was secure.
I agree.
Tragic as it is, the owners of the small breed should have taken extra steps to make sure it didn't get through the fencing. Especially since they felt the large dog showed aggression.
ETA: The dog was in it's own yard and it's not the owners fault.
hmmmmmmm That is touchy. Is the owner of the large breed dog home when this happened? or the owner of the small breed dog?
I don't know for sure but I think they were both home. Large breed dog owner brought the body of the small breed dog to it's owner with deep remorse. Small breed dog owner is now holding large breed owner responsible and saying things like that the large breed dog must have dragged the small breed dog through the fence (which doesn't seem possible).
Especially since they felt the large dog showed aggression.
No, she said the large dog has NEVER shown aggression. So maybe the owner of the small dog knew that and didn't see anything wrong with the situation.
Like this was my situation. My dog got into our neighbors yard, bc my neighbor's dog started digging into our yard.. my dog got through. He is a great dane and mine is a shih tzu, they played and both were fine.. but had something happened to my dog, I would probably have been furious. My dogs dont dig.
So more details are needed to your story IMO.
Large breed dog did not dig under the fence, I believe that there were small holes in the fence large enough for the small dog to squeeze through. Again fence belongs to small breed dog and the owner of the house larger breed dog rents from.
Especially since they felt the large dog showed aggression.
No, the large breed dog has never shown aggression. She is alpha, but I have had her in my home loose with my cats and kids without worry.
Were you watching judge Judy?> LOL
No, this is a real situation that happened to a Marine stationed here.
Oh, almost an identical situation happened on Judge Judy.
She ruled that the bigger dogs owner had to pay for the smaller dogs burial because she said they were negligent when it came to the holes.
large breed dog has not previously shown aggression like this and
Woops. I should have read it better.
None the less, I still don't think it's the large breed dogs fault. The dog got into the fenced in yard.
It will probably depend on who the fence belonged to...
AND if they could tell the small dog could possibly squeeze through, why wouldnt they have put something up to prevent something like this from even happening?
She ruled that the bigger dogs owner had to pay for the smaller dogs burial because she said they were negligent when it came to the holes.
In this case 2 houses own the fence. One does not live there and rents to someone with a dog much too large to fit through, the other has a dog small enough to fit through but did nothing. Perhaps they did not think the dog could fit? Could a renter possibly be held responsible for the holes in a fence?
IMO nobody should be at fault. If anything the owner of the small dog shouldve made sure the dog couldnt squeeze through. They shouldve put something up.
I say small dog owners at fault. Even if the large dog isn't aggresive but an alpha dog she is gonna protect her territory that is just how dogs are!! and who knows the little dog could have been trying to get the big dogs food/water/toy/bone whatever. My dog is not aggressive but an alpha dog and even though the kids and us can go by her toys food of whatever if another dog trys to go to it she will growl and show them who is alpha
Small dog was a 4 month old puppy of a small breed, not sure what breed, so it was very small.
why was such a small dog left outside without supervision?
Large breed dog did not dig under the fence, I believe that there were small holes in the fence large enough for the small dog to squeeze through. Again fence belongs to small breed dog and the owner of the house larger breed dog rents from.
Personally, I wouldnt have had a 4 month old puppy in the back yard alone. That age you are potty training and I was always out with my dog making sure they pottied.