Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

MC Times/ Pits banned from bases?

who's talking here?

♥my£ife 3
Mishka 1
EastCoast 4
LauraLee 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 5
Fancy Toy Parties Dot Com 1
Keaghan and Makennas Mommy 1
*Target lady has a secret* 4
Kristy 1
J.A.C.K. Here 1
Me+3 2
Ashleigh$DDCTTT 17
B*Bright 15
Jack Hass 1
MiDwEsTwIfEy 1
Fallonluvinmyboys 4
Going - Going - GONE! 6
PPCTMistyLa Diabla 1
Wowzers 11
ALS MommaKitty 2
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 3
Shainaღ 5
Lavender is Good 2
JLB88 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

So I just wanted to see what you all thought about it. There is a policy that if it passes, all pits & rotties and mixes will be banned from living on base. People who already have these dogs will have to fill out a waiver and get the dog "temperament tested" every 2 years. I think it may have mentioned also that if and when you change duty stations the waiver will expire. Meaning that you can't take your dog with you to the next base (BUT I could have read that wrong so this last sentence take it lightly and if you have these types of dogs check out the article for yourself!) Just thought i would see what everyone thought of it and how they would react about living on base if this passes.. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

* 

Wowzers --- 17 years ago -

I have no comment on the matter because I know this thread will turn into drama. 

Mishka --- 17 years ago -

I have no comment on the matter because I know this thread will turn into drama. same here 

Jack Hass --- 17 years ago -

I'm a big fan of getting them temperament tested. I have a pitt who is a big softie and she'd pass no problems. We knew when we got out pitt that we'd have to make some sacrifices and if we PCS then we'll have to live off base. 

MiDwEsTwIfEy --- 17 years ago -

Thats so sad and I wish that people would realize its not the breed its the people who raise them!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

Shainaღ --- 17 years ago -

Thats so sad and I wish that people would realize its not the breed its the people who raise them!!!!!!!!!!!!! exactly!! we have a german shepherd and we were apartment hunting and no place would take him cuz they have a "bad rep" thank goodness we got a house on base though so he can have a backyard =] 

*Target lady has a secret* --- 17 years ago -

well...looks like my dog would be on that list. Harley is a rottie/shep mix. I got a house in NC, so if we move back there anytime soon we are good to go. 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

Thats so sad and I wish that people would realize its not the breed its the people who raise them!!!!!!!!!!!!! This is true to a point. Aggressiveness has been bred into the breed. Even if you get a puppy that was never taught to be aggressive, it still may be. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

why will it turn to drama? i'm just asking peoples opinions on it..if you have a pit/rottie how do you feel about it? if you don't how do you feel about it. I for one, don't have a pet at all but I don't really have a problem with those types of dogs on base or anywhere for that matter. I do agree that all dogs living on base should be temperament tested though. That way we wouldn't have to ban certain breeds. I know they are more aggressive types, but if people treated them nicely it would keep a lot of the attacks down....but any dog can attack. they are animals. even a little yorkie can attack somebody, maybe not a fatal attack, but to a child or infant it could be.....some dogs (not breeds) are just big grouchy pants.....and temperament testing would be a good way to see which dogs (again not breeds but all dogs) have a good enough temperament to be allowed on base....or any community for that matter... 

Shainaღ --- 17 years ago -

oh yeah when we were stationed out in 29 palms pits and rots are allowed there either 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

Thats so sad and I wish that people would realize its not the breed its the people who raise them!!!!!!!!!!!!! This is true to a point. Aggressiveness has been bred into the breed. Even if you get a puppy that was never taught to be aggressive, it still may be. i agree with both of you.... 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

even a little yorkie can attack somebody Exactly. Any dog can turn on its owner. I agree, all dogs should be temperamant tested. 

EastCoast --- 17 years ago -

It's more than just pitts and rotts. There are a couple other breeds that are being considered. A lot of Marines get certain breeds for the look and the image. Staffordshires are not being banned, however. So, try proving that a staffordshire has no traces of Pitt. Whatevs. I think it's ridiculous, but it will weed out the owners who deserve their animals from those who are image-oriented when they are banned and people have to re-budget and fund a move out-of-pocket to keep their dogs. 

Shainaღ --- 17 years ago -

do u know what other dogs they are considering? 

Wowzers --- 17 years ago -

why will it turn to drama? i'm just asking peoples opinions on it. Because it's one of those touchy subjects that people will never agree on. I am not comfortable around Pitt Bulls, and would never let one of my dogs play with that breed. I'm sure I've angered some pitt owners by saying that and they will call me ignorant and yada yada. Sure, there are some nice ones with good temperament, but I am not willing to take the chance. I don't know the owner, I don't know the dog and given their reputation I am personally not willing to take the chance. Pitts can and have been known to switch gears very quickly. My cousin was attacked by one that had known her, her entire life... for no reason. The owners did NOT raise it to be aggressive, something just switched in the dogs head. Things happens, and I personally don't want to be put into a situation like that or put my pets into that type of situation. Regardless of how large or small the risk, I'd rather stay away. Others think differently, and I respect that. I kind of have an agree to disagree attitude on the topic. But, I wouldn't be upset about the ban. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

but it will weed out the owners who deserve their animals from those who are image-oriented when they are banned and people have to re-budget and fund a move out-of-pocket to keep their dogs. that is true, but i'm going to feel sorry for all the poor doggies that will go to the pound or rescue or be abandoned on the street because of these owners who don't really care for them in the first place... 

*Target lady has a secret* --- 17 years ago -

even a little yorkie can attack somebody when I worked in Petsmart in AR, I was grooming a yorkie. A bather was holding it's body for me while I was shaping the head. The thing went crazy--eye rolls and all-- and latched on to her finger and wouldn't let go. I swear it had the jaw clamp of a pit--haha--. She had to go to the ER and get stitches. Come to find out, the yorkie had been picked up by on owl when the owners let it out to pee. They didn't think it would make it because of all the damage done--the owl flew with it into a tree--. They said since that happened, the dog was always aggressive--even to them--. 

EastCoast --- 17 years ago -

Allegedly, German Shepards and Shar Peis are being considered as well. German Shepards are anything but aggressive USUALLY, but a lot of people get them, train them in obedience, and then train them to attack on command. Shar Peis were bred to be mean. They have always been bred for protecting and territorial behavior. I'm not sure either of those will be approved though. If they are, what does the MP force do about THEIR dogs?? 

Wowzers --- 17 years ago -

even a little yorkie can attack somebody LOL, but it's a Yorkie. Those are so small and easier to control. What are they, like 5lbs? You can't honestly compare a Yorkie attack to an aggressive 100lb dog attack. It's just incomparable. 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

why will it turn to drama? i'm just asking peoples opinions on it. Because it's one of those touchy subjects that people will never agree on. I think the order goes abortion, stem cell research, and pit bulls. Pitts can and have been known to switch gears very quickly. My cousin was attacked by one that had known her, her entire life... for no reason. The owners did NOT raise it to be aggressive, something just switched in the dogs head. I've owned pit bulls. At one time I had three puppies that came from a shelter. They were all raised exactly the same, with more love and kindness than any dog could wish for. They ran the gamut of aggressiveness. One was completely out of control aggressive to anyone and anything, one was as docile and placid as a cow, and the third fell in between. They were all raised exactly the same. I never had a problem with pit bulls until last summer. My 3 m/o son was bit by my best friends pit, completely unprovoked. The dog had been around my son plenty of times, it wasn't anything new to him. The dog sniffed my son in his car seat, and something went off in his head. He growled and snapped at my son's hand. Thankfully I was paying attention and kicked the dog away before he did damage to my son. Unfortunately pit bulls are one breed that have been damaged by man. In the 1940's they were THE family dog because of their loyalty and kindness. Then man decided to fight them, and now unpredictable aggressiveness is bred into the breed. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

target lady - awwwww that poor little thing....talk about some ptsd!! 

Fancy Toy Parties Dot Com --- 17 years ago -

I will be honest, I think it is bullshi* they want to ban certain breeds. I would take a pit over any dog and think that the people that complain about them need to get a life. I CAN understand people wanting dogs that are out of control, BUT that can be a freaking foo foo dog. I worked in a vet office, grooming salon, and petsmart and I hated the smaller dogs. (Some were nice, but more were mean then the larger dogs) I HATE hearing pits/rotts are know to switch gears, can change, etc. Come on, any type of animal can do that. The ONLY reason you hear only of pits is due to TV. If they reported EVERY dog bit, etc, I think all dogs would be put down by now. Last, I always like to point out that "PEOPLE" kill more people then pits/rotts. If we are going to ban dogs, why not just ban the human race??? 

Wowzers --- 17 years ago -

unpredictable aggressiveness is bred into the breed.  doesn't the aggressiveness also come from a defect caused by years and years of inbreeding? 

Shainaღ --- 17 years ago -

okay my german shepherd is afraid of everything and we dnt know why lol he's A HUGE BABY!!! any1 who has met him knows that and I've met some german shepherds at the dog park out in santa margarita who are very nice dogs also. ugh my hubby would be so upset if they ban them 

Shainaღ --- 17 years ago -

my mini schnauzer has more of a attitude problem the ace my german shepherd 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

doesn't the aggressiveness also come from a defect caused by years and years of inbreeding? That's also a part of it. 

Keaghan and Makennas Mommy --- 17 years ago -

Best thing about the MC Times is you can't believe half of what you read. Until Lincoln tells you no pits don't worry about it! 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

my mini schnauzer has more of a attitude problem the ace my german shepherd I've always thought smaller dogs tend to be meaner. I'm terrified of my friends 4 lb chiuaua(sp). That dog is the spawn of Satan. 

B*Bright --- 17 years ago -

do u know what other dogs they are considering? in the article i read, it said "pit bulls, rottweilers, canid/wolf hybrids and mixes of those dogs" i agree ecb....if they have german sheps why should other owners get rid of theirs.... i was attacked by a german shep when i was probably 15 or so...it was my fault though. This dog was trained to guard HIS house. I knew that when he was out front on his leash, NOT to go near him. It was my friends dog. I was walking up toward her house because I saw her outside and was going to stop by. I saw the dog on the leash outside but figured since my friend was outside too and talking to me in a friendly tone that the dog would consider things to be okay. well he didn't and he jumped up and started running toward me and my friend started screaming to run....so i started walking backwards (i didn't think the leash was long enough to reach me) and he bit/scratched me once and the force of him jumping on me sent me flying where he couldn't reach me. They got the dog & put him in the house and then they made sure i was okay...(it was just a few small scratches from teeth and paws but it was right on my girlie parts) but i got up and walked into the house and he didn't have a problem with me....i was able to go up to him and pet him without a problem.....because he knew that while he was on a leash he was to guard his family, but while he was inside, he was to greet people nicely...very smart dog if you ask me... 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground