Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Which would you choose?

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
RockinJanie04 2
CourtesyFlush 10
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 4
thetutulady 1
natalia 1
mamaold 3
Kristy 1
M.o.d.sfixyourself 2
Ashleigh$DDCTTT 4
CaliMommie 1
Su ^_^ 1
Carrie J 1
KayCee 1
TeamJohnston 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Which would you choose?

Ok. My son has been asking for a pet for a couple years now, and he's turning 5 on Friday so I figured why not. We can't have cats or dogs, but I was thinking about either a guinea pig or a chinchilla. Which would you choose? Anyone who has one or the other please tell pros and cons of what you have. Anything will help.

Guinea Pig Vote
 
 21.6% (8)
Chinchilla Vote
 
 32.4% (12)
Other(exlain) Vote
 
 45.9% (17)
CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

Ok. My son has been asking for a pet for a couple years now, and he's turning 5 on Friday so I figured why not. We can't have cats or dogs, but I was thinking about either a guinea pig or a chinchilla. Which would you choose? Anyone who has one or the other please tell pros and cons of what you have. Anything will help. 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

*Other(explain) 

RockinJanie04 --- 17 years ago -

a fish maybe? 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

a fish maybe? He's a fish murderer. 

RockinJanie04 --- 17 years ago -

oh 

mamaold --- 17 years ago -

Hermit crab. They are virtually indestructable. We had ours for a few years. It is a good break in pet 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

I can't even describe to you how loud and annoying Guinea Pigs can be. You might get lucky and a quiet one, but my little brothers kept the whole house up all night every night squealing. 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

oh lol. He dumped a whole thing of fish food in the tank and killed all the fish so I said never again! Not until he is older at least. He is gentle with other animals though:) 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

I can't even describe to you how loud and annoying Guinea Pigs can be. You might get lucky and a quiet one, but my little brothers kept the whole house up all night every night squealing. Oh no. Bad idea...lol 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

Hermit crab. They are virtually indestructable. We had ours for a few years. It is a good break in pet We can't cuddle a hermit crab though:( 

mamaold --- 17 years ago -

that is why I say hermit crab they are quiet reqire little maintence, kids can still play with them, they can change their environments and put a bigger shell and the crab will molt and change shells. best pet EVER for my kids 

Su ^_^ --- 17 years ago -

None. Mommy is lazy, plain & simple. lol 

thetutulady --- 17 years ago -

I hear both guinea pigs and chinchillas are a bit high maitenance... 

mamaold --- 17 years ago -

he kids can stll hold them and play with it. if you get 2 they can have races 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

in my experience, chincillas don't smell as bad as guinea pigs. my friend has a guinea and it STINKS. 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

in my experience, chincillas don't smell as bad as guinea pigs. my friend has a guinea and it STINKS. I was worried about that. 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

on the other hand, chinchillas can be pretty shy. maybe a hamster? they're usually pretty friendly and easy to take care of. 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

on the other hand, chinchillas can be pretty shy. maybe a hamster? they're usually pretty friendly and easy to take care of. Yeah I read that. I'm afraid he may not be gentle enough for one, and they are noctural I see so he would want to play with it during the day... 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

yeah that is true. my sister used to have one that drove me crazy at night running on it's squeaky wheel. 

M.o.d.sfixyourself --- 17 years ago -

the guinea pig squealing got so bad at night, my mom took them to her classroom as class pets. 

Ashleigh$DDCTTT --- 17 years ago -

the guinea pig squealing got so bad at night, my mom took them to her classroom as class pets lol 

CourtesyFlush --- 17 years ago -

the guinea pig squealing got so bad at night, my mom took them to her classroom as class pets. haha! I'm thinking of going the reptile route now. 

ALEM --- 17 years ago -

i had 5 guinea pigs at once(in my room). I never had a problem with them stinking, squealing during the night(i litter box trained one of them and he slept in my bed). If you use carefresh instead of the pine shavings(those are bad for their respritory system) it keeps the stink down alot. Max used to squeal when he heard a lettuce bag or carrots til he got some! 

Carrie J --- 17 years ago -

a bunny? 

CaliMommie --- 17 years ago -

the guinea pig squealing got so bad at night, my mom took them to her classroom as class pets. my sis in law used to bring home a class pet guinea pig for the weekend when it was her turn lol.. my mil says it was a nighmare.. my bil has a hamster and it plays on his wheel allllll night when we visit i think she trained it to do that lol 

TeamJohnston --- 17 years ago -

I have a certification in small animal care and health. And honestly , I think a rabbit of medium to large size would be optimal for a child that cant have an uncaged animal such as a dog or cat . Guinea pigs , though cousins of rabbits , are a little more tempermental in nature. And Chinchillas can get messy with all thier dust baths and what not. I showed , bred and taught rabbit care to FFA members And sometimes we'd do events with kindergarten aged kids..Rabbits are calm , and very well tempered if loved very much. AND .. Half of my rabbits (32 total) were litter box trained lol .. .. So maybe Im biased lol 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

I love my chinchilla!!!!! They are clean and easy to care for!!! Rabbits are messy IMO Guinea pigs are ok.... 

CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) --- 17 years ago -

I rats...they are so smart 

KayCee --- 17 years ago -

i would say a fish! haha i bought my son a hamster for christmas. thats what he wanted. i dont think he is old enough for the responsibilty of a big pet yet. hes afraid of it, because it moves soo much.plus the thing is awake all night. i dont know why it is soo noisy but it is. i regret getting the thing. 

natalia --- 17 years ago -

My daugther had a guinea pig and she loved it. She could take it out and play with it, she was able to take him in the back yard and play with him out there. He wasn't that loud and he didn't smell that bad. And he never bit her. Guinea pigs are great for kids....that is why a lot of class rooms have them. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground