Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

what age is too old for a pacifier?

who's talking here?

**ASH** 1
gidget 4
Dimples 5
Alexandra 1
KRISTIN 1
KayN 1
Monster* Mouse 12
Kristin 1
Mishka 1
sweetpants 1
retta 2
I am Bryant 1
Michelle R 1
wifeyfor10 2
Kawaii 1
B Bright 3
Drama Llama 3
SuperMom 007 1
Johns 1
EastCoast 5
whatevergirl ツ 2
RockinJanie04 3
JMudsy 2
D4Ski 7
CourtesyFlush 1
★ thEwrIghtwAy ★ 1
CPPrincess(Mystic chocolate) 2
Sarah aka Tippy 2
G's Wifey 1
Stacie 1
alfulkerson 2
Christina 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

D4Ski --- 18 years ago -

what age is too old for a pacifier? 

Dimples --- 18 years ago -

My son is almost 2 and he still uses them. I know I need to get rid of them but I feel so bad. 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

MY DAUGHTER IS 2 1/2 and is still using it doesnt look like she will give it up either. when the dentist looked at her 3 weeks ago she said not to worry about it til about age 4 but have regular dental care. 

JMudsy --- 18 years ago -

I've heard several different things, but I'm going to go with 1. After that there's no way it could NOT have an effect on their teeth. 

JMudsy --- 18 years ago -

well ok then, I stand corrected...lol 

Dimples --- 18 years ago -

My son's teeth have already shifted so of course his doctor said to get rid of it. But it breaks my heart to take it away from him. He loves that thing!!! 

B Bright --- 18 years ago -

i personally think you should get rid of it whenever you get rid of the bottle or a little before the bottle or a little after the bottle...taking bottle and paci may be a little to traumatic to them...but i think 2 years old is too old...i think 1 and a half is to old....but then again, its your child and you have every right to have your own choice...i'm not gonna see you in the street and be like...omg you need to get rid of that paci your such a bad mother...i won't be like that...i'll just see the kid and then think to myself...aww he looks cute with his paci, but i think he's a little old for it.... so i guess i'm just trying to say i'm not a die hard no paci person...LOL... 

**ASH** --- 18 years ago -

I took my daughter off the binkie at 9 months! I sucked my thumb till I was 5 and didnt want her to do that with her binkie! 

B Bright --- 18 years ago -

if your doctor said you need to get rid of it, then do so.... you can try unique ways to do it by "donating" it to another baby who doesn't have one (then throw it away behind the kids back), uhm...do a coming of age ritual type thing where baby needs to get rid of it and the kid finds all his paci's puts them in a jar and then throws them away himself..(jon & kate did that), accidentally "forget" it at the hotel on vacation (or the beach)...there are plenty of different ways to do it... i just quit my daughter cold turkey on it because she got thrush (at 6 months) so she wasn't addicted to it or anything...but i did find myself wishing i still had it when she would cry i would reach for the baby bag and try to find a paci to give her...LOL>. 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

my daughter threw he bottle of me at 9 mon so i thought she will do it with this damn binky LOL but she will have a fit from hell and worse. and i was relieved when the doc said its ok and that its better to have the binky then a bottle.believe me i hope she gets rid of it and i'm thinking about just letting her have it for the night but since the Dentist told us she be fine. 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

omg u guys have to see my daughters LOL she has a frog attached yes I said frog and walks around with that thing haha. I have to say to that she has special needs and the attachment is a bit harder to get rid of it just like the thing that use to be a cute cuddley monkey lol so those things are her security 

Dimples --- 18 years ago -

I'm pushing for just at night. I really don't mind it. I think it's cute and with so many changes going on in our household, the last thing I want is to do that to him. Maybe after we move, get settled and he's in his big boy bed 

D4Ski --- 18 years ago -

 

D4Ski --- 18 years ago -

ok the reason i ask is cuz.. (kinda a long story) My daughter almost 2 is a monkey well she hurt her arm yesterday and she wouldn't use it so i took her to the ER.. she ended up pulling her elbow out of its socket by climbing out of the Pack n play. so any how.. the nurse comes in and Kelcie is sucking away on her pacifier and the nurse takes it out of her mouth and says you don't need that. ( i must tell you Kelcie is obviously in a lot of pain and daddy left us for the first time 2 weeks ago and she just started her "terrible twos") so you can imagine how she reacted to the nurse taking the binkie away. so the nurse says we need more x-ray (at this point kelcie had a broken elbow) so she wanted Kelcie to walk with out her binkie and her blanket. ( the blanket is the next best thing to calm Kelcie) Kelcie freaks again. i cant believe the f-en nurse did that too her. oh then i am even more mad at my self for not doing anything about it. well i did but i just went against the nurses wished but i sure didn't b*tch her out. 

Dimples --- 18 years ago -

Yeah my son has this mangy looking stuffed dog that he can't be without (that and his "mine" pacifier). He pratically shoves the dogs tail up his nose. I can always tell when hes tired because he will sit with his mine and rub his dogs tail across his nose. Yes my son is weird, but it's kinda cute :) 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

oh she had no right to do that. hell no i would have said give me the damn thing back. i'm the one taking it and no one else. nobody at the peds ever takes it from my monster. they love the Frog to much i think lol 

Dimples --- 18 years ago -

Wow, that nurse has some nerve 

B Bright --- 18 years ago -

desiree - don't let anyone tell you (unless its a dentist or a doctor) when to give up the pacifier. i mean, people can give you their opinions, but it's ultimately up to you....when my daughter was younger i took her home to see my family and my g*ma and my sister would always take her paci from her...and they would say the same thing (you don't need that) but i would always tell them she is my child and she can use it if she wants and i would give it back to her...but we weren't rude to each other... 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

i agree B bright 

gidget --- 18 years ago -

i believe that the pippy should go before they can walk. there is nothing worse than a baby walking around with a pippy. that is my opinion but every kid and parent is different. i don't really have an opinion when it comes to stuffed animals or blankies. to each there own. 

gidget --- 18 years ago -

don't let anyone tell you (unless its a dentist or a doctor) when to give up the pacifier. i agree, even though i hate it....why does it matter what i think? i don't have to deal with your child screaming and crying you do. make the decision for your self 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

lol gidget PIPPY?? to cute. 

gidget --- 18 years ago -

thats what i call it. i'm silly 

Stacie --- 18 years ago -

Any age, it's too stressful to wean them, neither of our children had one. I am so sorry the nurse did that to you, some nerve. 

D4Ski --- 18 years ago -

lol gidget PIPPY?? to cute. truly adorable i got so much shit from my MIL for trying to take the binkie away.. i got Kelcie to go to sleep one night without it and i was sending an e mail to my MIL about it ( you know the hole Kelcie is a big girl now she went to bed with out a binkie) and she replied back to me not to do it and she sent a copy to my hubby! what kind of shit is that so hubby get up to take care of her the next morning and gives her a binkie after i told him i got her to go to sleep with out it. so that messed it all up. Thanks ladies! i am going to wait till Daddy gets home before i do anything. that is in two months. i feel bad for you wifes that have to put up with the kids behavior for longer then two months. i give yall lots of credit. cuz mine is not deployed he is at school. so i can't even imagine the visions and dreams you have. 

Drama Llama --- 18 years ago -

Im not going to read this whole thing, but when they told me at her day care they didn't want them anymore, I started to cut the tip. I was like "oh no binky is broken" she would be upset but still try to suck on it and then just hold it when she couldn't suck anymore. It too about 2 days... I am lucky right now my son could care less about pacifiers 

Sarah aka Tippy --- 18 years ago -

Was it at the NH? I got crap from a nurse there for letting my very sick 1 1/2 year old (at the time) have her blanket. Ignore the nurse. See if your child really needs it or just uses it because it's there. If the second is the case, as it was for my daughter's bink, I just let her lose them all and as I found them I just put them away some place she couldn't find them. I was shocked... she never missed them at all. She's turned two this month and been bink free for about 4 months now. 

Monster* Mouse --- 18 years ago -

LOL voodoo i had thought the same thing and gave her a broken one and it broke more oh my god i had the worse screaming fest at my house like u killed her and sadly she will repeat the same word over and over and over nothing can take her mind of it, i said after this one and one more that i have it be it no more. so i will try the only at night thing but hubs probally will sabotage it when i have surgery on the 24th i just know it. 

D4Ski --- 18 years ago -

right now she is using the binkie all the time. she is really upset about daddy being gone. but normally she only gets in at nap time and night night time oh and when she gets an boo boo. i keep it out of reach any other time. 

D4Ski --- 18 years ago -

oh and when she gets a boo boo i try to get her to comfort her self with the blanket instead of the binkie but if she is in to much pain i give her the binky. and yes it was the NH. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground